REPLY TO ADAMO , KEY ET AL . , AND SCHILLING AND CRUSE : Crawlingaroundthehardproblemofconsciousness
نویسنده
چکیده
Barron and Klein (1) define consciousness very narrowly, excluding most of the attributes commonly associated with it (e.g., self-awareness). By limiting the definition to a form of information processing, they find that insects qualify. However, just to put this conclusion in perspective, by the same definition, some robots are also conscious and capable of subjective experience. Autonomous, self-navigating robots with motivational circuitry [e.g., (2)] fit Barron and Klein’s definition of a conscious entity (1). These robots create an integrated “neural” simulation of themselves in space and use appropriate internal and external information to do so, and their behavior can be influenced by theirmotivational state (3). Like a bee, these robots can actively hunt for things beyond their immediate sensory environment, something that the Barron and Klein (1) argue is a key requirement for subjective experience. These robots often use biomimetic neural structures, such as central processors with feed-forward, feed-backward, and recurrent connections. These artificial brains allow robots to integrate information, have motivational goals, direct attention to salient environmental features (i.e., exhibit selective attention), and make appropriate behavioral choices (3, 4). Although these examples of artificial intelligence (AI) show impressive abilities, even the AI community does not consider them as examples of consciousness (3). The analogy between circuits within the insect cerebral ganglion and vertebrate midbrain is interesting, but the enormous difference in neuronal number between the two raises the possibility that some elements that may be critical for consciousness are missing in insects. For example, insects do not appear to have circuits that subserve emotional behavior in the same way that vertebrates do (5). Insects appear to be under greater selective pressure than vertebrates to reduce the cost and size of their brain (6). This pressure probably reduces selection for traits such as subjective experience (e.g., emotional experience) in this group. Although I do not disagree with Barron and Klein (1) that comparative neurobiological studies will help us understand the evolution of neural mechanisms for a wide variety of abilities, I am not sure that I would look to the insects to learn about the evolution of consciousness. The constraints on the size of insect nervous systems (6) may preclude its development in this group. Therefore, Barron and Klein’s conclusion that insects are conscious (1) is surprising, only because the word “conscious” carries certain connotations. Stripped of the term “consciousness,” their conclusions are not controversial. For example, a bee without the ability to “simulate the state of the animal’s own mobile body within the environment” would be incapable of foraging and navigation. What is surprising is not that bees can form neural simulations of their environment, but the labeling of this ability as consciousness.
منابع مشابه
Anticipation and the control of voluntary action
A major hallmark in the adaptive control of voluntary action is the ability to anticipate short and long term future events. Anticipation in its various forms is an important prerequisite for cognitive abilities such as planning, reasoning and the pursuit of both immediate goals and long-term goals (e.g., to invest in pension funds) that sometimes stand in opposition to immediate desires and ne...
متن کاملGains from diversification on convex combinations: A majorization and stochastic dominance approach
By incorporating both majorization theory and stochastic dominance theory, this paper presents a general theory and a unifying framework for determining the diversification preferences of risk-averse investors and conditions under which they would unanimously judge a particular asset to be superior. In particular, we develop a theory for comparing the preferences of different convex combination...
متن کاملImproved immunogenicity of tetanus toxoid by Brucella abortus S19 LPS adjuvant.
BACKGROUND Adjuvants are used to increase the immunogenicity of new generation vaccines, especially those based on recombinant proteins. Despite immunostimulatory properties, the use of bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) as an adjuvant has been hampered due to its toxicity and pyrogenicity. Brucella abortus LPS is less toxic and has no pyrogenic properties compared to LPS from other gram negati...
متن کاملSteady electrodiffusion in hydrogel-colloid composites: macroscale properties from microscale electrokinetics.
A rigorous microscale electrokinetic model for hydrogel-colloid composites is adopted to compute macroscale profiles of electrolyte concentration, electrostatic potential, and hydrostatic pressure across membranes that separate electrolytes with different concentrations. The membranes are uncharged polymeric hydrogels in which charged spherical colloidal particles are immobilized and randomly d...
متن کاملPerturbative Analysis of Dynamical Localisation
In this paper we extend previous results on convergent perturbative solutions of the Schrödinger equation of a class of periodically timedependent two-level systems. The situation treated here is particularly suited for the investigation of two-level systems exhibiting the phenomenon of (approximate) dynamical localisation. We also present a convergent perturbative expansion for the secular fre...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2016